Yesterday I introduced the Time-to-Point Ratio using Lords of Waterdeep as an example, but the game that really made the concept clear to me was the new game Splendor from designer Marc Andre and publisher Space Cowboys. First, I must just say I love this game. It's an elegant engine-building race to 15 points. Here's a good tutorial of how to play.
Usually whoever reaches 15 points wins, though there is a chance of any close stragglers catching up on their last turn. Because there is no hard limit on the number of rounds like in Waterdeep, Splendor is a little trickier to reverse-engineer. Fortunately all the cards have been structured in a very regular cost-to-reward structure, which can be converted to this basic rule of thumb:
Each card requires a number of turns equal to its cost.
The whole game is built around breaking that rule, compelling you to build an engine that lets you to buy cards faster, more cheaply, for greater reward, or simply removing them from the market so an opponent can't take them. So let's look at the cards you can buy and their relative costs.
Usually, costs are structured so that every card costs a resource matching another card's color. For example, in the cheapest cards: Red costs White, White costs Blue, Blue costs Black, Black costs Green, Green costs Red. These patterns vary, but within each reward-category, a five-pointed cycle is always embedded in the cost structure.
First Level Ratios
- 3 for 0 Points: Two to Three Turns
- 1 / 2 for 0 Points: Two to Three Turns
- 2 / 2 for 0 Points: Two to Three Turns
- 1 / 2 / 2 for 0 Points: Two to Four Turns
- 1 / 1 / 3 for 0 Points: Two to Five Turns
- 1 / 1 / 1 / 1 for 0 Points: Two to Three Turns
- 1 / 1 / 1 / 2 for 0 Points: Two to Three Turns
- 4 for 1 Point: Two to Four Turns
Second Level Ratios
- 2 / 2 / 3 for 1 Point: Three to Six Turns
- 2 / 3 / 3 for 1 Point: Three to Six Turns
- 5 for 2 Points: Three to Five Turns
- 3 / 5 for 2 Points: Four to Seven Turns
- 1 / 2 / 4 for 2 Points: Three to Five Turns
- 6 for 3 Points: Three to Six Turns
Third Level Ratios
- 3 / 3 / 3 / 5 for 3 Points: Four to Six Turns
- 7 for 4 Points: Four to Seven Turns
- 3 / 3 / 6 for 4 Points: Five to Seven Turns
- 3 / 7 for 5 Points: Five to Six Turns
It's also clear now that costs with as few types of colors are best, especially if they're even numbers.
- 4 / 4 for 3 Points
- 3 / 3 / 3 for 3 Points
Splendor uses very regimented costs and rewards throughout the card deck, to the extent that there is a five-pointed web dictating that X-color card will always cost Y-color of resource. It's a great example of how to begin with a crystalline distribution, then use the vagaries of random draws and engine-building to add lots of texture. It's a fantastic game and a wonderful design. Bravo, Marc André!